Part 1 here!
https://www.reddit.com/r/sexstories/s/nVtjbGWqb0
I don’t know why the lube wasn’t in her bedroom, but she returned with it after a couple minutes. Unfortunately by that point, a lack of stimulation had half-deflated me. That’s when she did the last thing I expected. Moving down to suck my dick back to life, she instead ran her tongue against my asshole, before pressing it inside. I squeaked out an alarmed protest, before succumbing to just how good it felt. I had spent my entire life in fear of anything regarding my ass, but let me tell you, if you haven’t been eaten out, you’re missing out. She sufficiently lubed me up and with a bit of work began lowering herself down my cock, her hips violently bucking when she was about 2/3rds of the way down. “I’m sorry, I’m just not used to feeling dick like… so thick” She moaned out, before managing to reach the base. Holy shit, her pussy was the best pussy I had ever felt. So hot, wet, soft, it was like heaven enveloping my cock. She slowly lifted herself up, before lowering herself again, steadily bouncing on my cock, discouraging me when I began to thrust as she was still getting used to me. “You like this pussy, you little slut?” She moaned out, pulling her shirt over her head as she picked up her pace. “You like giving up your fat white dick for weed, little whore?” She smirked, my hands reaching up to grab her tits. All I could do was moan back a ‘yes ma’am’, as it had been a while for me too, and I was doing everything I could to stop myself from cumming. “Fuck, I’m in love with your dick, I’m gonna fucking cum!” She moaned, having stopped bouncing, just rocking back and forth on my cock. “I’m close too, Lexi, I’m gonna pull out.” She slapped my face, shock ran over my body. “You’re not gonna fucking move until I cum, bitch. Cum in this pussy, give me a fucking baby.” She moaned, her hands pushing down on my chest. Before I could even protest, my dick exploded in her from the dirty talk, shot after shot of cum painting her cervix as I tried to catch my breath. Apparently she came too, but I was too out of it to even notice.
“Fuck, Big Guy, I actually felt you cum in me.” She laughed, running a hand through her hair. “Don’t worry, I’m on the pill. I hope I wasn’t too rude to you there?” She asked as she climbed off my dick, it flopping onto my stomach. “No, it was pretty hot.” I chuckled, watching my cum drip out of her. “Don’t tell Lukas, okay? Like, he can’t find out.” It was like I fell back to earth, immediately dropping from my high. Holy fuck, I just fucked my best friend and roommate’s sister. “Oh my god, he can’t find out, he’d hate me!” “I dunno about hate, but I’m sure he’d be pissed at both of us. When do you wanna do this again?” So, that was how we fucked the first time, as best as I can remember it (some things may be missing/out of order, but I really couldn’t forget something like that). If anyone wants to hear any of my other stories, either with her or not, I can make a part 2 or something? But yeah!